Submitted by Fred on

Dad's 104th Birthday

Categories
Holidays

Today is my Father's birthday and 18 years after his passing I am just starting to miss him. 

Why am I just starting to miss him? He was a "Damon Runyon" ("Guys and Dolls") character, emphasis on character, to the outside world. Although he was a tough SOB and especially hard on his first born son he is finally starting to get through to me. In the early 80s I wrote a painful piece about him and here are some excerpts which will impart some of his "flavor":

 

A short, bald, stocky, fun-loving drinker
 who married late for who knows why.
 He was known to say to her,
 "I picked you up out of the gutter
 and I can throw you back."
 He was never seen at home,
 just heard rolling into my sleep --
a loud and roaring drunk.
 But he was self-made and, of course, Great.

 He had meager time for me and
 he never ever spanked me.
 But, I overheard him sneer that he would buy my love
 and at 16 he gave me a convertible and changed my life.
 Suddenly I was a Big Man too.

 When it came time for college
 he advised me that I'd be "taking up space". 
He told me I was a "bum" and should go to work.
 His disapproval extended to my marrying for love
 and not for money --
a very low percentage "sucker move".

 Then came the summers I worked for him --
he rode me hard trying to  
simulate his own apprenticeship.
 His workers whispered "Little Hitler"
and how could I help but hear?

 

You're tired now
 and your piss and vinegar
 have run dry.
They say you've mellowed,
 but what about me 
old man?
 It's never too late. 
Please, just once,
 tell me how good a boy I am
 and how much you love me.

 

He was tough and hard, but now I find myself constantly quoting him, e.g., "My father said there is nothing new under the sun", "My father said nothing is ever said in jest", "My father said get on their level", "My father said you can get more with honey than vineger", "My father said never give a sucker an even break", "My father taught me to live within one's means", etc., and utilizing interpersonal skills he somehow transferred to me, e.g., "Give a firm handshake and look him in the eye" . 

Now I wish he were around and more mellow, so I could hear his stories and ask for his counsel. Happy Birthday Dad! I miss you! I miss you a lot!

Comments

Benjamin Geizhals

I am certain of one thing. Although I am not sure how he'd express it, he'd be proud of his son.

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Thu, 01/02/2014 - 22:34

Permalink

I miss m y father everyday..........

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Thu, 01/02/2014 - 22:42

Permalink

Field of Dreams

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Thu, 01/02/2014 - 23:00

Permalink

Nice Pop! I know you.
-Alex
Dana Charlton

Fred, that's a beautiful tribute to your Dad. I remember him, because he visited you at our offices on both 5th Avenue and Madison Avenue. It was evident to me that he loved you! Happy Birthday Mr. Klein!

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Thu, 01/02/2014 - 23:29

Permalink

I hope as he got older, he told you how much he loved you and what a terrific and accomplished son you had become, something that all of us at Gotham recognize the minute we meet you. How proud he must have and should have been and how lucky we are to know the Fred Klein that he helped create and shape. Happy Birthday to your Dad from all of us and thanks to him for making it possible for all of us to know and love you. Dr. Gerry Goldhaber

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Thu, 01/02/2014 - 23:32

Permalink

How you could miss a stinker like that is amazing,happy new year Arnold
Fred Klein

Thank you all for your heart felt comments (and keep them coming)!
Flo Feinberg

Fred, perhaps you too have mellowed over time...
It's amazing how much we need our parents' love and approval.... That's one reason shrinks exist!!

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Thu, 01/02/2014 - 23:48

Permalink

I feel very sad that you did not know a father's love. It probably made you stronger, but he sounds like a very selfish, angry man. You turned out right not because of him but in spite of him. I didn't know him but I loathe him.

Submitted by Fred on Thu, 01/02/2014 - 23:51

In reply to by NULL (not verified)

Permalink
Fred Klein

Please identify your self
Fred Klein

Photo is of my parents on their wedding day!

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Fri, 01/03/2014 - 00:00

Permalink

Tough story. So different then my own. Hard to even know how to respond. I know that when growing up most of us are shaped by the good and bad of our parents. Some with wonderfully kind and generous parents might have been better with tough love. Others with tough parents develop such a deep insecurity that they can never overcome it. In your case the tough guy your dad was made you stronger, perhaps you developed your strength to say screw you dad, I made it in spite of you...But you developed the strength to be the success you are today. I'm guessing that your mom was not so tough and showed you love and kindness. The combination is probably what shaped you into the multi-dimensional and great guy you are today!
Ester Horowitz

> You know what Fred.... You surpassed your father. Don't include the
> line getting more with honey than vinegar because he didn't apply that
> to you. My Mom could be as harsh as your Dad.
> Even though many things stick, what also sticks is the fact that at 53
> years old, it took her to loose her leg and that of both my brothers
> before she heard her friends say often enough that she had an amazing
> daughter. So much that for the one and only time She did say I was
> amazing. She died 18 months later. My Father died never saying it.
> What he did say was that I was a "Berkowitz" (maiden name) and rising to the occasion was expected so there would never be any accolades or "I'm proud of
> you" for doing what was expected.
>
What they didn't understand is that there is a difference between rising to excellence versus perfection. Perfection is elusive. Excellence is on going born of trial and error. They never let me forget my errors and would bring it up when ever an argument ensued.

I learned later that it was unfair and dirty tactics. I also learned later
how to forgive and understand that they were doing what they thought
was best for me even if I didn't agree.

Submitted by Fred on Fri, 01/03/2014 - 00:20

In reply to by NULL (not verified)

Permalink
Fred Klein

I will forever recall my mom whispering "Be a good boy Freddy" constantly in my ear!

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Fri, 01/03/2014 - 00:30

Permalink

Nice tribute. My Dad was milder in manner, but a workaholic too. And my grandfather gave me many similar expressions of advice.....I truly appreciate your feelings at this time, especially. Happy New Year. AM
Tessa Marquis

Sad. It is too bad, but I feel sorry for your father, pushing people away so that love couldn't be shared with him.

My parents married for love and my mother loves him still, although he died on this date 18 years ago.

Her "boyfriend" didn't mind. He got the next 15 years with her! Love is all that matters. That is the true mark of success.
Jane Jacobs

I vividly remember you introducing me to your father. On the way to the Friars, where we all had a drink, you told me it was ok to decline if he asked me out (I was probably 27 or so and he was probably in his 80's). Not only didn't he ask me out, he deemed me unworthy of his pinocle game. I was mortally offended.

And I will never forget your eulogy.

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Fri, 01/03/2014 - 01:35

Permalink

Your dad and my dad must have been friends......

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Fri, 01/03/2014 - 01:37

Permalink

Soul nourishing recollections Fred. He cut his own cloth and you yours. I saw him with you and know he was proud.
Marc Halpert

My father warned me when I left Richmond VA to start my first job in NYC "Your're too soft-they will eat you alive." Not quite the sage send-off advice I would have been able to draw upon in a tough moment.
35 years later I wish I could introduce him to all the amazing friends and trusted colleagues I have in NYC through Gotham.
Memories...I still miss him though.

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Fri, 01/03/2014 - 01:44

Permalink

you got me with this one. my dads been gone since '78 and i wish he could see how happy i am that I live within my means and make them better every year and that i've met some great people like you who really do make life worth living every day. To Life and to Family!
Charlie Schreiber
Tessa Marquis

@Marc_Halpert My mother's words as I ran to the plane to NYC
"And stay away from Andy Warhol!!!!!'

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Fri, 01/03/2014 - 03:15

Permalink

I always appreciate the way you share so much of yourself. You set the tone for Gotham. Somehow you turned out to be the accomplished, supportive, person who grew a wonderful family of your own and who along with Nancy gave rise to the Gotham family of giving, concern, charity etc. I imagine your Mom had a great deal to do with getting you through, and now you see some of the morsels of good your father may have had. Maybe it shows if enough time passes we can find the good in anyone:) Sherry
ODEY RAVIV

Very Moving stuff Fred and commenters! Our Paternal and Maternal memories and love (or seeming lack of it), have an incredible impact on how we live and think about everything.
Fred Klein

My mother constantly whispered "be a good boy Freddy"

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Fri, 01/03/2014 - 06:19

Permalink

Very eloquent. Keep the comments coming.

--The Suck-Up Counting Commissioner

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Fri, 01/03/2014 - 09:39

Permalink

"Nothing is ever said in jest....." You said that to me this morning as a matter of fact! re: our mutual and crazy friend ! That beautiful white corvette !! Was it a '58 ? Well...It blew me out of the water with Janet and Joanne.. Although I was driving a brand new Morgan 4+4 at the time. NOTHING had the pizazz of that big rumbling V-8! Your dad knew what he was doing. By the way. You gotta find out about that hat. I think it belonged to Myer Lanski of the Miami Mob....Fred...Be thankful you had a dad with character who expressed his love in different ways...Vince Lombardi had a similar approach with his players. If you could put your arm around him today at the age of 104 I guarantee things would be different. He taught you to be able to say the things that you never heard from him to your own boys. He taught you how to be a loving father and husband. Obviously not by example. The way we run our own morality at this stage can be a direct result of how well or how BADLY we have decided to be. You are a GREAT guy Fred with that little touch of naivety that people love. Be careful with it. One thing your dad never did I would guess was betray you. That's what I live with. And so...On his 100th birthday this year I still felt betrayed. My friend the aging psychiatrist we talked about today once told me...." Because they are blood you don't necessarily have to love them...." Thought provoking.

P.S. Get out and dig another Poop Circle for Charcoal. This one is history. You will find it in the Spring !

Hollander Sends

Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on Fri, 01/03/2014 - 10:15

Permalink
Erik Scheibe

Thank you for sharing
Corey Bearak

I came to this late and what interested me is the 18 years. 18 -- apart from being my fave #, if created with Hebrew letters, spells Chai -- LIFE. Fascinating that 18 years later, your dad's birthday coincides with you blogging date.
Parents profoundly influence their offspring sometimes passively, sometimes proactively, sometimes benignly. Sometimes we only learn those lessons later in life, long after they leave us; sometimes it occurs when we take on roles they've had.
Some things I do because of my dad; others I avoid doing for the same reason.
Just know you learned your lessons well...and it made me think of me think of a song with the lyrics, "But it's all right now, I learned my lesson well... just have to please myself."
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uAHR7_VZdRw
and an updated version by my fave singer:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5_SzvvE3vO8

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Sat, 01/04/2014 - 00:15

Permalink

Well done, Fred, and thanks for sharing. What does this say about nature vs. nurture? Or does it say more about the resilience of the human spirit, at least in a segment of our species (happily, you occupy a spot at the top of that food chain...). We learn from all of our experiences. Some are downtrodden by them, and others rise as a result.
David Abeshouse

That last one was from me, Fred (re: "well done," etc.). The website sometimes signs us out without notice, and I don't think to check whether I'm signed in, when reading a blogpost and posting a comment. Mea culpa, sort of....

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Sat, 01/04/2014 - 02:03

Permalink

Anyone who can provoke that number of comments must have a good deal on the ball, which describes you pretty well. I was looking for some comment about the Yankee Stadium (or was it Ebbets Field) baseball seat that enhanced your office. Let me add my tribute to those that either were anonymous or acknowledged their identity. I have such fond memories of the meetings in the Friars Club and elsewhere.
One includes the occasion when I stopped at your house after playing tennis to get dressed to go to the city, and Joanne gave me one of your ties to wear. I think when you saw me, you said, "There but for the grace of God...." or, if you didn't, you should have. After one of our meetings, I went to a meeting of the Board members of the Wildlife Legislative Fund at the Metropolitan Opera (one of the Board members was on the Met Board), and during the opera, another Board member turned to me and asked, "Henry, do I like this?" If you will invite me to the Friars Club, we can have a reunion and perhaps even negotiate a contract. If you do, I can check whether Bucky is still around and the reminiscences will be audible miles away. Until then, my best
wishes and you'll soon be hearing from me. Henry Foner

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Sat, 01/04/2014 - 03:36

Permalink

Makes me think of my dad who, passed nearly 3 years, still lives within. I recall also, with fondness, hearing from you, returning from a Gotham Oyster Bay swim meet, other stories about your dad. Good memories. Rick Raymond
Rona Gura

It's amazing how all of their actions have an effect on us. I try to keep that in mind in my own parenting. But, it's hard.

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Sat, 01/04/2014 - 17:35

Permalink

I'll never forget the first time I met him. He scared me.

Submitted by SoniaSaleh on Sun, 01/05/2014 - 01:38

Permalink
Sonia Saleh

Fred your thoughts are heartwarming. My dad died 18 months ago at 86 and for most my life we weren't close, we couldn't communicate, he was a workaholic, and we were just contrary. His last 5 years he moved back to his homeland, Egypt. I'd go annually to visit, and we talked on the phone often. Now I have a thousand questions for him, about immigrating, about his success, about his life, about his choices, about ours, and so much more. During my visits to Egypt, as I was stepping into my new, scary business, he told me he was proud of me and loved me. And I was astonished, elated, and overwhelmed. As I write it brings tears to my eyes. Fred, Thank you for giving me a beautiful memory.

Submitted by Lucas_Meyer on Sun, 01/05/2014 - 23:11

Permalink
Lucas Meyer

Thanks for sharing a part of your life with us. My take-away is that given your relationship with your father and telling us all about it makes me feel that I've gotten to know you better. In past meetings, conversations, etc., you alluded many times to your relationship with your father, and now I have a greater understanding of what it entailed.

My own father was married four times. As you know, he had a difficult "assignment" during the Second World War, which probably made him rather cold towards his wives and children. He's been gone thirteen years... I can't say that I miss him a lot.

Add new comment

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.