Submitted by Fred on

The Dylan Movie

The Dylan Movie
Categories
Movies

We saw the new Dylan movie, A Complete Unknown, this past weekend and it was so good that I can't wait to see it again (and for a post 1965 sequel)!   

Of course, I am his contemporary and it resonated on the growing up together level, it was like Edward R. Morrow's bygone "You Are There" TV series. 

The performances are extraordinary, with at least 2 Academy Award winners: Timothee Chalamet as Dylan and Edward Norton as Pete Seeger.  

Supposedly,
Chalamet and the actress who played Joan Baez, Monica Barbaro, learned to sing and play guitar for their roles. If so, the flick is even more extraordinary!

Another noteworthy performance is by Dan Fogler who played pushy, gross Albert Grossman, Dylan's Manager.  

With the above as prelude, I wonder who the deep down Bob Dylan really is?

Enigma is too simple a word to describe him.  I wonder, day to day, if he even knows himself. He seems so nasty, contrary, withdrawn, stoic and lonesome.  Is he on the spectrum?  Is he for real?

Whatever, he has all the iconic Super Star credentials.  He has done it all!

I ponder what I would say if he was alone and I came upon him (as I once did with Elvis)?

Surely, I would seek to relate to him, to get on his level as my father taught, and inasmuch as Robert Zimmerman pledged Sigma Alpha Mu fraternity in 1959 (at different colleges) the same year I did I could say "Hi Bobby, we are brothers." :)

Who knows?

Comments

Benjamin Geizhals

Thanks for the review. Can’t wait to see the movie. Seeing him in concerts over the years, raised the same questions about him.
Daniel Schwartz

I know so little about him as a person, but grew up listening to his music as my family were fans. I am very curious to see the movie now.
Ray Walcott

Happy you liked the movie! It's nice to consider how we might relate to the real Bob Dylan.
Shelley Simpson

I suppose if you came upon him, had you not seen the movie, you would ask him to tell you his life story in 5 minutes or less as you are won't to do.

Submitted by Judy_Mauer on Thu, 01/09/2025 - 20:41

Permalink
Judy Mauer

I LOVED. The movie. For a week after I saw it - I watched every doc, interview, and movie about him. I was obsessed. Joanie Mitchel thinks he’s a phony and a plagiarists, Joan Biaz was heartbroken when they split. He is an enigma- I know people who worked with him - and they actually couldn’t get a take on him. You couldn’t have a conversation with him because it didn’t make sense. Having said that - I loved the movie - having lived it in real time….. and loved his music. He is phenomenon. I believe he was a channeler - he was writing as fast as he could, it came pouring out of him and it was pure gold. There is no denying the quality of his output. His music and lyrics are genius. Blood on the Tracks is one of the greatest albums of all time. I recommend Testimony by Robbie Robertson. - great bio of him and lots about the band and their time with Dylan.
Robert Intelisano

Loved the movie as well, am considering seeing it again.

Submitted by Steven_Lichtenstein on Thu, 01/09/2025 - 21:34

Permalink
Steven Lichtenstein

Timothee Chalamet is a Frenchman and yes he did study for this role for several years. He learned how to play guitar, sing and even captured Dylan's mannerisms. He personified Dylan's affect including his brooding and somber rock star personae. I am a big fan of much of Dylan's catalogue (Blood on the tracks, Highway 61, Blowin in the Wind, etc.). It is amazing to me that he's still touring even though the voice is strained, he still fills concerts halls and led the way for other musicians to solve their estate planning liquidity issues by monetizing his catalogue. I decided during the movie that this would win best picture and best actor. With all of the other crap being made, this is a gem. Make sure you see it on the big screen.
Norman Spizz

All managers are pushy and gross. I deal with them every day.
ODEY RAVIV

One of the great Bio Pics. Director Mangold had a great idea in focusing the movie on a 4 year window. It is hared to believe, and Fred has his doubts, that all the performers playing Dylan, Baez, and Norton learned to play and sing as they prepared for the movie. The delays because of Covid and the Actors Strike gave them lots of extra time. It was nice to see so many interesting comments and great to see that so many Gothamites actually went to a theater to see a movie not named Oppenheimer or Barbie!
Fred Klein

Great comment highlighting the comments. Best comments ever! Thank you all for reading and feeding back. This is how it should work!
Matt Plociak

I loved the movie and I'm a big Dylan fan. The thing that I find so fascinating is Dylan's songs/words seemed to chronicle our time (I'm a Boomer) and our feelings of those times. But, whenever Dylan was interviewed and asked about a particular song and it's meaning he basically said it's just a song. Be that as it may, I agree that he deserved the Nobel Prize for Poetry. This movie was an homage to Dylan's genius...BTW, PBS has been showing actual clips of Dylan at Newport Folk Festival 1963-1965. He was much better in the movie...

Add new comment

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.