Submitted by Rona_Gura on

Is It Real News?

Categories
Lifestyle

A friend and I had a bit of a debate this week. She had her view on a certain issue and I had mine. To support my view, I emailed her a news article I had found. She did the same. We had two different viewpoints on the same issue, but each was apparently supported by two different news articles.  The websites where we each found the articles were very reputable websites.  

 

I read the news online every day.  There have been days where I feel the need to “fact check” the website where I get my news. I generally do this by checking a different website. I remember checking back and forth between websites often during the disputed 2020 election. 

 

I have always been a “news junkie.” As a teenager and young adult, I  remember watching Walter Cronkite religiously every night with my Dad. We both also read The New York Times every day. We never ever questioned anything that Walter Cronkite said during a news broadcast. Nor did we question what we had read in The New York Times. We would discuss the news and  articles we had read at length but neither me nor my dad would ever, back then, question the validity of  what was being reported.

  

When and why did that change? When did we become distrustful of the news and the people delivering it to us?

Comments

Corey Bearak

I have my trusted news sites but IF Stone always argued aim for original sources. I do not believe in reputable new sites reporting any variance in facts; there op-ed sections could conflict but that is commentary. Off site I'd like to now the new sites in conflict.
Gregory Rose

Agreed! Look who they are quoting in the article and believe them. Generally speaking though I think you could still get most of the information you'd like through popular news sources - eg. NY Times, AP, and the like.
Daniel Schwartz

Owners (or person in charge) of the network choose what to broadcast and how based on their political viewpoints. Simple as that. Today, there is no unbiased news so fact checking is constant.
Paul Napolitano

Great, thought-provoking blog Rona. I commend you for questioning the news! When big tech has so much control over what is out there, you never know what to believe. What’s even more scary, is that most of the fact checking websites are biased also!
Flo Feinberg

And so the question of who to trust remains… it used to be so simple; never trust anyone over 30….
Is there an exception for Bruce Springsteen?
Shelley Simpson

Back in Detroit, we had two newspapers. They reported the same stories from different perspectives. When I worked in DC part of my job was to read all of the print media and much of the internet which at that time was not so much. We then compared and, again, the same news reported from different perspectives. So not much has changed other than we have more sources of information and it remains incumbent on each of us to determine what makes sense because it confirms our pre-existing notions or what we wish were true and what doesn't make sense because it flies in the face of what we see. And of course, follow the money/agenda when it comes to the source.
Stephen Redford

Where to begin. My father lives in Florida and I live in NYC and we arrive at the opposite view of the same issue consistently. I think it all changed due to the 24-hour news cycle (CNN, etc.) and the need to make news entertaining and garner high ratings. This is exacerbated by social media, which makes anyone with a website and a facebook account a source of news. Throw in outside money from large corporations that seek to influence the news and we have a problem. I would welcome the day if we got back to reading local newspapers. I think internet and social media has ruined everything. BTW, I am a website designer! :)
Rona Gura

I find your comments about social media really interesting. It's a great point, in this day and age anyone can deliver the news.
Rona Gura

Good point about the fact checking. I get my news from one station that's, obviously, one side of the politic spectrum. But if I question it, I check it against the news website that's at the other end.
Rona Gura

They don't conflict on the "big story," i.e. when both Fox and CNN called the election for Biden. But they do conflict on some of the small stories of the day.
Stephen Redford

I think Social Media has pitted us against each other like never before. Not just politically.
RitaSue Siegel

I have always been skeptical of so many things I read in the newspapers. (The New York Times every day.)I recall when reading about our bombing of Hiroshima that our press did not tell their non-Japanese readers the true story of the death and destruction caused by our nuclear weapons. Every time I hear a certain type of declaration having to do with politics, international relations, war, and so on, I say "wait until the memoirs, biographies, autobiographies, or the histories are published." Although those too can be influenced by the truth or falsehoods writers and journalists are privy to, it is difficult to make a definitive judgment about much of the stuff we read in the papers or what passes for news from the various sites we may follow. (One of my favorites is the BBC app.) I do not listen to TV or radio news. Remember the evidence of Saddam's weapons of mass destruction, supposedly George Bush believed it, and his sidekicks Cheney and Rumsfeld tried to make us believe it, but there weren't any. And lastly, the Vietnam War, if ever there was a barrage of fake news it was the narrative of what was taking place there. American readers did not know we were losing and probably never had a chance to win if that was ever in the cards.

Add new comment

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.