Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on

Mob Rule

Categories
Health

I woke up this morning feeling like I had a horrible nightmare, feeling like I'm mourning the death of my closest friend. But to have to accept the fact that it's reality is a nightmare itself. No one knows the pain that the media & unwanted opinions from the public has caused my family. To make us relive a moment in our lives that we regret everyday is a horrible thing.

To take something away from the man I love that he has worked his ass off for all his life just to gain ratings is horrific. THIS IS OUR LIFE! What don't you all get. If your intentions were to hurt us, embarrass us, make us feel alone, take all happiness away, you've succeeded on so many levels. Just know we will continue to grow & show the world what real love is! Ravensnation we love you!"

That was the statement issued yesterday by the victim in the Ray Rice tragedy, Janay Palmer Rice.

While everyone else in the world was patting themselves on the back at what they had accomplished (they being the public and the media), the woman that had taken the brunt of the abuse, was feeling abused all over again.  Let's see, first you get punched in the face, then you get humiliated all over the television, then your family loses possibly the last $16M in income they may ever make.

With advocates like that, who needs abusive husbands?

Hurt, embarrassed, alone, unhappy...that's how we have made her feel.  That sounds an awful lot like the feelings that abused women have described...except that he didn't do that to her, we did.  We have now become the abuser of the woman who was assaulted that night in the elevator.

The only thing worse than an abusive husband is an unemployed abusive husband.  The worst part about this entire situation is that despite everything the rejoicing mob believes they have contributed to the cause of domestic violence, they have done nothing, not one thing to curb domestic violence.   In fact, if anything, this torch and pitchfork led effort has in all likelihood made it worse.  If you think that victims are hesitant to come out and report it now, imagine what these women will do now that they can be assured that their family will lose its income and be publicly humiliated.

People are scared to death.  You can see it in their faces as they are interviewed.  They will do and say anything just to escape the angry mob and the damage they can inflict upon you if you are not careful.  Robotic, terrified responses.

People can speculate whether this was a case of an abusive husband who got caught, or a couple who just had the worst drunken night/fight of their lives and made huge mistakes (his obviously much worse than hers).  I don't believe that the original suspension was enough, but I also don't believe that the situation as we know it justified completely destroying this family and their relationships (they named their daughter "Rayven" after the team they both spent the entire lives with and were now ejected from).    Everybody felt completely comfortable describing Janay as an abused wife and assumed that she is just acting the way all abused wives act.  I've even seen newscasters offensively rolling their eyes and scoffing at her reaction.  The truth is though, nobody but them know, and she seems pretty adamant that it's not the case.

The law showed mercy on them and allowed them to enter a domestic violence rehabilitation program that was probably designed by domestic violence advocates.  You can choose to agree with that or not.  The league suspended him 2 games, which probably wasn't enough, but whether it was 2, 4, 6 or a full season probably wasn't going to change much of what happened or what would happen to others in the future.  But all of that wasn't enough for people.  It wasn’t enough red meat to make people feel better after they were forced to watch the injustice on that video.  They wanted more.  They didn't want more because it would help Janay Palmer Rice.  They didn't want more because it would deter domestic violence in the future.  They wanted more because it would make them feel better...and we are nothing if not self-indulgent and dedicated to our own instant gratification.

If I had to honestly choose between taking a punch to the jaw or being feasted upon by this savage, hideous monster, having my life completely destroyed in the process, I would take the punch to the jaw...but that's just me...and probably Janay Palmer Rice.  I can't speak for anyone else.

This whole horrific fiasco will do nothing but deter women from speaking out and testifying...and most of them won't have videos of the crime with which to bother us.

Comments

Fred Klein

Fiasco it is when the NFL is concerned. Tragedy for the couple and hopefully they will continue together.

Submitted by VikramRajan on Tue, 09/09/2014 - 23:34

Permalink
Vik Rajan

Wow, you're not pulling any punches, eh? This is not an ethical matter, it is a legal contractual matter. If Ray is not representing the nfl the way they expect players to conduct themselves, then the contract can be terminated. Personal & professional partners of high profile professionals must consider media attention: good & bad. Yes, victims can be blamed.

Submitted by MarcKarell on Wed, 09/10/2014 - 06:13

Permalink
Marc Karell

I agree that this was an overreaction. The video proved nothing. The earlier video showed Ray dragging Janay like she was a bag of garbage. How did she end up in that shape? She accidentally fell and got knocked out? No, everyone knew she was hit. Even if the NFL was telling the truth (and with their reputation at risk, I am not sure they did), they had to know it was pretty bad. Now that the new video came out, they make him the fall guy. But honestly, I do not have a lot of sympathy for the couple, especially of losing millions of dollars. That's a lot of money and as Vik wrote well, part of making so much more than the average person makes is the behavior clause, which he broke, not to mention, the law.

Submitted by StephenMichel on Wed, 09/10/2014 - 06:53

Permalink
Stephen Michel

I do have sympathy for the couple. They are human, no matter how much money they make. They made a mistake. If they were an unknown couple, then no one would complain about the punishment they received. The idea is to stop this kind of abuse. Better they get therapy and learn to avoid this in the future. The NFL and the Ravens just succumbed to the mob. The mob want blood and they got it. Who among us have done something wrong and we thank God it wasn't publicized.

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Wed, 09/10/2014 - 06:54

Permalink

I am amazed at what I read above..."make him the fall guy", "I hope they continue as a couple", "this is a legal matter". wrong, wrong, wrong. This is only a legal matter as it affects Rice and the NFL. He is the fall guy! He slugged her, spit on her and dragged her out before I understand he kicked her. Do you guys really think this was a first? This is a legal, ethical, and moral situation. I truly hope she gets out of this situation before he kills her and before she gets pregnant because a man (and I use the word loosely) who does this to a women is only inches away from doing this to a child.

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Wed, 09/10/2014 - 07:24

Permalink

I totally agree with Anonymous above. I found it hard to read the 'excuses' from so many of you! He PUNCHED her....Abuse excuse is no excuse. When are we all going to learn not to make excuses. This behavior is not acceptable and her response is totally that of someone abused.....and losing 4 million a year income! This will never stop until we see this kind of behavior as totally unacceptable. period

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Wed, 09/10/2014 - 08:25

Permalink

Link: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/09/10/ray-rice-domestic-violence-hotline_n_5798462.html?1410369898

The National Domestic Violence Hotline has seen an 84 percent increase in phone calls in the two days since a video leaked of former NFL player Ray Rice knocking his then-fiancée unconscious in an elevator.

Katie Ray-Jones, the CEO of the hotline, said it normally receives 500 to 600 calls a day from domestic violence victims and their concerned friends or family members. But after the Rice video was circulated online Monday, the hotline received over 1,000 phone calls. The numbers continued to climb on Tuesday.

"We had an outpouring of women saying, 'Oh my god, I didn't realize this happened to other people.' They thought they were living a life that was very unique to them," Ray-Jones told The Huffington Post. "One woman called in who is married to a [mixed martial arts] fighter. She said, 'I just saw that video, and I know my husband could do worse, and I need help."

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Wed, 09/10/2014 - 08:28

Permalink

Are you kidding me? Rice is a monster that deserves to lose his career. What message des it send to kids if he gets to be exonerated for beating a woman or anyone else for that matter. It is disgusting. Sorry it was brought up again but it was not handled properly in the beginning. I hope the couples therapy worked but that is just a band aid. He is a bad seed that deserves nothing. When his wife can find her footing she will be ok. Don't you worry. Staying with him or keeping quiet because of the money is just WRONG!
Corey Bearak

This is a tough one because of the victim impact where the victim chooses to maintain the relationship. Will not try to get inside that thinking. I just know so much assistance is out there in terms of counseling and more for DV victims.

Submitted by NULL (not verified) on Thu, 09/11/2014 - 03:39

In reply to by Fred

Permalink

It's easier to be a part of the mob when you can stay anonymous. You can make comments as if people are making excuses or exonerating Ray Rice (i haven't seen anyone, anywhere do that). You can slip back into the narrative that you are comfortable with rather than dealing with the points made in this particular essay and dealing with this particular situation.

Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on Thu, 09/11/2014 - 04:51

In reply to by NULL (not verified)

Permalink
Erik Scheibe

I believe when Marc referred to "Making him the fall guy" he was referring to Roger Goodell, not Ray Rice. I have no idea if it was the first time, nor does anyone else other than the couple. You cannot declare that it is a pattern of abuse based upon how other people have reacted in their situations. It could be true, but it is not fair to them to condemn them for it while they deny it. As Janay said, it is their life.

Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on Thu, 09/11/2014 - 04:54

In reply to by NULL (not verified)

Permalink
Erik Scheibe

I found this comment shocking, as if it pertained to a different blog. Who made any excuses? Who has indicated at any level that this behavior is acceptable? You feel comfortable characterizing her behavior based upon other people's experiences? Perhaps you could explain how someone who had not been a victim of do estic violence would have reacted? Her initial comments were reported as "How could you do this to the mother of your child?" She certainly moved towards him as if she didn't have any expectation that he would respond like that. I know I would never go after someone that big like that who I thought was dangerous. Part of my blog was not blaming the victim, but defending the victim who has clearly been thrown under the bus by those supporting the cause. It is important not to neglect the welfare of the victim in favor of the effort.

Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on Thu, 09/11/2014 - 04:56

In reply to by NULL (not verified)

Permalink
Erik Scheibe

I understand the concept of the profile of the battered woman. This does not mean that she should automatically be treated this way. It is possible that what they are saying is true. We have no justification after one incident to assume that she is lying.

Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on Thu, 09/11/2014 - 05:36

Permalink
Erik Scheibe

Let me also add, that I think that this is a significant and difficult societal problem. I always flinch when people try to solve problems carelessly which I think is my biggest concern here and the main point of my blog. When you just attack and wreak havoc, people panic, see Roger Goodell...people lie, people hide...people are afraid to speak (see racism). This is by no means just an NFL problem, although if you want to look at propensities, combine wealth, entitlement and growing up in violent neighborhoods/homes/situations and you'll probably find higher rates of domestic abuse. Not everything can be solved through punishment and intimidation (ironic statement, no?). I can't imagine that most of these incidents are thought through. I can't imagine that the people who do this feel that there is nothing wrong with such abuse. There is no place in society where this is openly accepted. Not in the locker rooms. Not in the cigar bars. Nowhere. I would imagine that this comes down to flaws in people's nature and character.

I have written before about this issue. There seems to be an increasing portion of our society who are (as I call it) "banged up". We can debate the chicken and the egg all day, but common threads of drugs, poverty, physical abuse, sexual abuse, poverty, broken families, etc. pervade in these situations. People do not just end up in these situations through bad luck (on either side). I am not judging anyone, when values are compromised, when a child's self-esteem is compromised. When children are exposed to violence or worse, the dice are rolled and the results can be tragic. I am not excusing any behavior and don't think that punishment is wrong, I just don't think that punishment alone is going to solve the problems.

There were opportunities to learn from all of this, regardless of whether Ray Rice was a serial abuser or if this was a one-time tragic marital fight. There is no one person or group that is to blame for this (as the title of the blog indicates), but instead of kicking the door open with a flamethrower and watching everyone scatter for their lives, this could have been used to teach and to try to fix people. Now (and we may be pretty close already) people are just going to be sick of hearing about this. People will do and say anything just to get themselves out of the crosshairs and onto someone else. We now have the former head of the FBI investigating the NFL investigation of an incident that we saw in its entirety on videotape. This could have been an opportunity to help the fight against domestic violence, a problem that virtually everyone is disgusted by. Instead it's just scorched earth and an increased deterrent for women to come forward and launch themselves into the tempest.

Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on Thu, 09/11/2014 - 05:43

In reply to by VikramRajan

Permalink
Erik Scheibe

The blog really had nothing to do with a team's right to terminate a contract.

Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on Thu, 09/11/2014 - 05:45

In reply to by MarcKarell

Permalink
Erik Scheibe

You are correct that the video proved nothing. Everyone knew everything that had happened in the elevator as the Rice's (probably after knowing the existence of the video) were honest about what happened inside the elevator. The public seeing it enraged people, but it really didn't inform on anything new. I don't feel bad for Ray Rice, but I do feel bad for his wife and daughter.

Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on Thu, 09/11/2014 - 05:48

In reply to by NULL (not verified)

Permalink
Erik Scheibe

Also, just so you know, they have a two year old daughter, named "Rayven". If there is a pattern of abuse, then I would agree with your assessment. If this was a one-time incident, then I think the comment is unfair.

Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on Thu, 09/11/2014 - 06:55

Permalink
Erik Scheibe

This just in, the SF 49ers announcer has just been suspended by the team for two games for criticizing Janay Palmer Rice for going in front of the commissioner the way she did. The mob rolls on.

Add new comment

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.