Elite?

Categories
Health
Tags
DNA, DNA testing, athletes, power athletes,

Friday evening I received a text from my daughter. She advising taking a DNA report. It involved nothing about confirmation of me as her biological dad. No need to go any further on that thread.

 

The DNA report she shared advised my daughter’s “genetic muscle composition is common in elite power athletes."  I muse back, “It makes me want to get one.” I added, “Wow.” She replied, “Do it!!!”

 

I suspect Marisa’s interest in DNA emanates from her interest in family genealogy; she done some research in that regard.

 

I know almost nothing about the test she used but she found its “traits report” as accurate. It also provides ancestry composition; I found those findings interesting based on my wife’s Sephardic heritage on her dad’s side (Indeed an apartment at the Lower East Side Tenement Museum bears his family name.).

 

The testing suggests at-risk diseases as well. A little research advised that only last year that the Federal Food and Drug Administration (“FDA”) approved at-home genetic testing (for 10 diseases). When it approved this kind of test, the FDA also made clear genetic risk alone remains one piece of “a bigger puzzle” and does not mean someone will or will not develop a disease. Indeed, lifestyle and other factors play a role.

 

The disease piece played no role in my interest in the test. The “elite power athletes” reference caught my attention, and not just because Marisa attracted my attention with that comment when she disclosed her test results. I immediately shared it on the Gotham sports listserve and received some gratuitous comments. Another – an excellent athlete – advised thank you and he owes me a meal; we did not discuss what he plans to with the information.

 

I also shared it with a few friends after our weekend full-court game; some teasing resulted of course.

 

It certainly makes me wonder whether I missed some opportunities back in my day.  Frankly just getting on the court twice a week (most times) satisfies me.

 

As to being "elite," many ways exist to achieve that label, and not just in sports.

 

So any thoughts on testing and whether to confirm whether a certain phrase might apply to this correspondent?

Comments

Fred Klein

My grandson Jackson remembers your performance at the picnic on the softball field.

Submitted by MarilynGenoa on Sat, 03/03/2018 - 22:02

Permalink
Marilyn Genoa

Very interesting - positive and worrisome at the same time. I suspect your talents are myriad and hope the path chosen has been satisfying. It certainly has been, from what I’ve seen in the short time I’ve known you, a positive one, for many you have touched.
Rona Gura

I've been curious myself about it. According to the ads many people find unexpected genealogy. It amazes me how readily available this sort of information is.

Submitted by AnthonyVerna on Sun, 03/04/2018 - 01:06

Permalink
Anthony Verna III

Have you ever read the privacy policies of commercial DNA companies?
Corey Bearak

You raise an interesting issue. Thank you for contributing to this discussion.
Corey Bearak

I had fun with the elite athlete piece since most of my life I tended to be not of that physique.....
The accuracy was an issue with FDA some five years ago. Only approve this test less than a year ago.
Corey Bearak

when I played with an injury when I should have just sat out?
I think I told you I enjoyed my best ever year at the plate when I endured a leg injury and got replaced by a courtesy runner when I reach base.
Corey Bearak

Yes. I did not post the %'s but considering Shelly's Sephardic heritage I found Marisa's result very much skewered to the regions where I know from my ancestors emigrated. And also some interesting items if they apply to me which you'll remind me to chat about next time we see each other.
Corey Bearak

Always so generous and sweet with your comments. Always much appreciate here.

Add new comment

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.