Submitted by Rona_Gura on

My Payroll

Categories
Lifestyle

I am very proud to say that all four of my children are college graduates and, in fact, two have their Master’s Degrees and have great jobs. The younger two are in the process of getting their graduate degrees; Ryan just finished his first year of law school and Sydney will be starting in September a combined program for her Masters in Special Education, Elementary Education with an additional certification in Applied Behavior Analysis. My husband and I are very proud of all four of them.

 

So, here’s the question that my husband and I are now struggling with, at what point do our young adult children come off of our payroll? I am not talking about direct payments of weekly sums to help them sustain themselves while in school but, rather, the indirect support they still receive. All four of them are still on our cell phone plan for which we pay. In addition, our oldest daughter, Danielle, recently came off of our EZ Pass account and we are pushing our next oldest daughter, Calli, to get her own account. So far, that hasn’t happened.

 

Some friends have told me that they still have their adult children on credit card accounts, which we terminated after each child graduated college. I was shocked to hear that a colleague, until very recently, was still paying for her adult daughters’ (both of whom are married with adolescent children) gas for their cars. That, to me, sounded extreme.

 

 

At what point did you cut off your kids?

Comments

Fred Klein

I can't remember, but I still pay for an AAA card for one.
Corey Bearak

Very provocative question. I pay the mobile account. My son pays the netflix. He used to pay for the WSJ but we decided not to continue it; He pays for the Economist which he reads on line and I read in print which comes to my office. We have one account for Apple apps. Most of these things make sense. My daughter recently moved some things I paid for on a joint card to her own card. The joint card with just her had gone unused for months and probably confuses the bank. For emergency purposes there is a shared family card. Whether a child needs help or not, if a parent has means, my view remains do so.

Submitted by MarilynGenoa on Mon, 06/12/2017 - 04:50

Permalink
Marilyn Genoa

Hmmm. Interesting.
Rona Gura

Interesting about the NetFlix. Calli recently moved to Bayside and told us she took minimal cable. She then told us that's because she signs in-on her smart tv-to our Netflix, HBO etc.

Submitted by NeilHollander on Mon, 06/12/2017 - 06:12

Permalink
Neil Hollander

Yeah wow ! Provocative indeed . Diane and I are often in conflict about child rearing philosophy . I'm the guy who pushes the enabling and Diane the opposite . She's a Minnesota farm girl who still has the first dollar she earned
Picking green beans for Jolly Green Giant in Blue Earth Minnesota. Me ? Mr . Extravagant . Dugout seats at Yankee Stadium and dinner at LUGER 's . Seriously , cell phone bills , car insurance , AAA , I paid way too long and angered Diane way too long . It's called parenting Fred once told me . Maybe it was my way of not letting go . I still fund their IRA's every year . Why ? Says Diane . Why not ? I say !
Age ranges 24-36. 5 college degrees. 7 grandkids .
Hollander Sends
David Abeshouse

Rona, I don't have time to type out all the thoughts I have on this one. Suffice it to say, our twins, who graduated college 4 years ago, returned home for 10 months after graduation to build their NYC apartment rental war chests (but insisted on contributing toward household expenses, which we let them do, and then we surprised them by returning all the $$ to them as a gift when they moved into their apartment). Since they moved into their apartment, they've been off the company payroll except for incidentals, such as the family cell phone plan, which we're happy to do. And I've voluntarily (!) contributed decreasing amounts to the first three years of their Roth IRAs. And every now and then, we make a nice gift, with the stipulation that ~90% of it is for savings/investment. But there's no expectation on their part, and no requests, which to my mind is mostly what counts. I do think that it's different for every set of parents and kids. And I'll leave it at that, for now.
Victoria Drogin

This is all really interesting. We are not there yet. On the cusp with Allie and Justin graduating from college next year, Derek the year after, and Dana just 16. Keep us posted! Paul and I generally think that when they graduate school and get a job that's when the gravy train ends!
Nancy Schess

Such a great question. Ask me in a few years. There is much graduate school in our future!
Cayce Crown

I don't have children so my opinion is worth what you paid for it. However, as a child who got my parents to pay for things well into adulthood, it wasn't a gift, though I thought so at the time. I had to learn things about responsibility and self support in my 40s & 50s, that I could have learned in my 20s if I hadn't been indulged. Get your children to be self supporting independent POWERFUL individuals. The world will be a brighter place the more we all take personal responsibility.
Rona Gura

We actually let Calli live at home-rent free-for the first year after she graduated grad school so she could save money. Same concept as you I guess, different execution. :)

Add new comment

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.