Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on

Evolution

Categories
Lifestyle

Recently Rob Portman, Senator and perennial presidential candidate wrote an op-ed piece for CNN.  He not only announced a philosophical change in his belief on gay marriage, but also described the intellectual process by which the change occurred.

This is not a piece debating gay marriage, but rather a discussion on breathing room and tolerance for those to change what they believe in.  Some may be skeptical, and we have certainly seen recent accusations of high-level political figures on both sides of the aisle changing their stance solely for political purposes.  That's why the explanation of how his evolution transpired has value.  It doesn't just have value in that it helps us believe him.  It has value because it shows how one's thoughts and emotions can be affected when an important and controversial topic is viewed up close and in real life rather than from a distance.

I have written before about how my views on gay marriage changed maybe 12-15 years ago (certainly a lot sooner than some "intellectually superior" liberals).  We often see those who are the champions of intolerance respond likewise with intolerance.  We live in a more polarized and vitriolic era than I have ever experienced.  We are all empowered to speak, to hate, to be outraged, to criticize, to judge...to attack.  Ideas and speech are squashed more violently now than I've ever seen before in my lifetime.

Some change occurs through protests, law suits and battles in the streets and on the endless wire.  Yet some change occurs merely through education and evolution.  We have to give people room to think, to evolve, to explore thoughts.  Without the development of ideas, without the room to change, it is literally the intellectual evolution of mankind that will be stunted.

 

Comments

Submitted by Vincent_Serro on Wed, 03/20/2013 - 00:33

Permalink
Vincent Serro

I don't think too many people have the same opinion on every topic over their entire lifetime. Everyone evolves over time. For most people that evolution comes from life experience. However, with certain politicans it may have more to do with political posturing. It's hard to believe most politicans that change their mind on hot button topics since too many of them believe their primary job function is to get re-elected. I hate to use the word "phony", but a lot of them do tend to believe in what the opinon polls tell them is the most popular position quite frequently (especially as we approach a new election).
Mitch Tobol

Is it a well thought out political move? Or a window into the thinking and maturation of a politician?

Submitted by Lucas_Meyer on Wed, 03/20/2013 - 04:09

Permalink
Lucas Meyer

My view on gay marriage has changed completely. Previously, I argued that some changes in the tax code would level the playing field; therefore there wasn't any need for same sex marriage and that gay couples could go to their priest, minister, rabbi or imam to get married before God. But it was a combination of being at a dinner party with a married gay couple and a Libertarian schoolmate of mine who asked a simple question (Where in the Constitution does it say that marriage is between one man and one woman?) that changed my mind. At the dinner party, John and Barry (who have been together for over twenty years) were just like any married couple, they clearly care for one another and as we left our host's house, I said to my wife that my view did a "one-eighty".

Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on Wed, 03/20/2013 - 06:02

Permalink
Erik Scheibe

It is pretty easy to see in this case that he change is real considering the situation with his son. It does say a lot about our aggregate skepticism though, how little we believe public figures anymore. Considering Obama and Hilary have come out recently as well and changed their positions, I wonder if your political ideology affects your level of skepticism?

Submitted by Erik_Scheibe on Wed, 03/20/2013 - 16:01

Permalink
Erik Scheibe

Fred, you being serious or sarcastic, it's pretty big on my end. Have to get used to the pargraph breaks though. They show up on my computer, but not in the actual blog
Corey Bearak

In the Jewish faith the concept of daily/weekly study of the Torah/ the weekly reading for the sabbath and the readings traditional on the festivals anticipates we will glean something new no matter our age; thus it forms a basis for an informed we continue to learn throughout our lives. (evidently difficult to post via mobile if you want to log in, thus the delay)

Add new comment

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a href hreflang> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <code> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id> <h5 id> <h6 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.